Friday, May 23, 2014
Book Summary: "Cleaning House, A Mom's 12-Month Experiment to Rid Her Home of Youth Entitlement"
So here's my summary (and favorite quotes from the book) since this topic seemed to peak the interest of many of my friends, I hope you find it helpful!
Kay Wills Wyma is a mom of five who came to the realization that she was not doing her kids any favors by doing for them what they were capable of doing themselves. A generation of overserved kids is being raised and those kids are growing into adults who think the world revolves around them. She decided to do a 12 month experiment with hopes that she could "equip, teach, and then let go". It's not that any of us want to raise overindulged kids, we just find that's it easier to do things for them our way, and avoid the battle. I could relate to her quote, "I've always tried to be a mom who doesn't hover, but apparently I've done much more than I realized."
"With the greatest of intentions and in the name of love, we have developed a tendency to hover, race to save, protect from failure, arrange for success, manipulate, overprotect, and enable our kids. Freeing their schedules for sports, school, and increasingly important time with friends, we strive to make our children's lives easier or to make success a sure thing by doing it all for them. We shower them with accolades, proclaiming how wonderful they are - yet we rarely give them the opportunity to confirm the substance of that praise. All of our efforts send the clear, though unspoken and unintended message "I'll do it for you because you can't" or "No sense in your trying because I can do it better and faster."
Month 1: Beds and Clutter
Starting off simple and with the goal to fight the urge to do for them what they could do themselves, the children will make their beds and declutter their room/bathroom every day. Wyma decided to give each child a jar with 30, one dollar bills in the jar. If the job was not done she would take a dollar out of the jar and at the end of the month the money left was theirs. (We do not currently do any type of allowance so at first I thought this was way too much money each month but as I read the book I realized that as she added jobs each month she did not increase the amount of money in the jar. This could be marbles, quarters, anything. Also, when I do this with my kids I will be making my bed too. I'm pretty laid back and it's not a priority for me, but I can see the bigger picture is to help everyone become personally responsible for their things.)
"The motivation associated with potentially losing a dollar is much greater than the incentive to gain a dollar."
"Decluttering has been one of the keys to success in our equipping activities. I've noticed that with the kids the less clutter they have to deal with, the better their ability to maintain a clean space. Okay, so maybe that's true for me too."
Month 2 : Kitchen Patrol
Each child will take a turn being in charge of the evening meal one time per week. This includes menu planning, shopping, preparing the meal and doing the dishes. Wyma's goal is to come alongside the kids and teach them how to find a recipe, shop in a grocery store and cook. It doesn't all magically appear in the fridge and on the table. (I want to try this with my older kids. I don't think the 4 and 5-year-olds are ready for this one yet, although they can be helpers!)
"It's pretty easy to protect and provide for kids. You keep them physically safe, give them an abundance of fun things to do, and they grow on up easily. That's the American way. The better way is to prepare kids for independence, but that is a much harder task. As they develop, we should slowly reduce the protection and provision, while increasing the preparation."
Month 3: Planting, Weeding, and The Great Outdoors
This included decluttering the yard (toys, shoes, wrappers that end up scattered), pulling weeds, and planting flowers (teaching them to choose according to the amount of shade and space needed, etc. Planting a garden together would be a good idea too!) She also included odd job postings where the kids could earn money for doing extra jobs like sanding and painting chairs, washing outer windows, etc.
"What is the antidote to overindulgence? Give them work...meaningful work."
"In our society, children are generally not required to do meaningful work to help their families. Going to school, pursuing their extracurricular activities, and staying out of major trouble is considered their function. In the old days, boys and girls had chores and roles that were vitally important to the survival and functioning of their family unit. They knew that they were an integral part of the survival of their family and that without their contributions, it would suffer."
Month 4: Gainful Employment
It is important to answer to an authority other than parents. Adolescents wouldn't get full time jobs but would look for opportunities to babysit, wash cars, lawn care, walk dogs, etc.
"And while I'm not opposed to a bit of summertime relaxation, I don't want the kids to enter adulthood expecting every day to be fun, another message I suspect we've mistakenly planted in this generation by our parental tendency to entertain rather than challenge our children."
"These days, employers see a disturbing trend of exactly that: employees who walk away from the job when the work proves more demanding or less interesting than they expect."
Month 5: Domestic Dirty Jobs
Teach the children how to clean a bathroom. Wyma also focused a lot on doing the job well the first time. Learning to persevere and go the extra mile rather than doing just enough to get by.
"It's so hard to let my kids handle their business, especially when 1) I'm fairly certain I can do it better, 2) I know other parents are stepping in for their kids, 3) I equate helping them with loving them, and 4) I'm just not sure my kid will actually get it done. To the latter I need to genuinely let my brood swim floaty-free much earlier than senior year applications so I know they can do it and so they know they can do it."
Month 6: Dirty Laundry
Each child will do his/her own laundry, start to finish. As always, she will work alongside them to teach them how and then let them do it alone. (I like this one. I have a lot of laundry. Right now my kids age 5 and up put their own laundry away but I see no reason why the older ones can't wash, dry, fold and put away their own stuff. Maybe they won't be so quick to put things in the dirty basket?)
"Our kids need to know how to persevere. They need to know that no job is beneath them. They need to know what it takes to operate a home. They need to know that sometimes you have to get dirty to get things clean. They need to know how to serve. They need to know that a family operates as a unit, everyone pitching in. They need to know that they belong, that they are a part of the group, that they are needed."
Month 7: Home Repair and Maintenance
Take advantage of teaching opportunities like plunging a toilet, changing a light bulb, unclogging a drain. They may sound simple but have the children ever had to do it before?
"The fact that God trusts us to help him with the tasks of the kingdom is proof positive that he loves us deeply. And I want to show that kind of love to my kids."
Month 8: Party Planning and Hospitality
Each child will plan and host a party. It can be small and simple.
"Hospitality gets your eyes off yourself and onto others."
Month 9: Team Players, The Benefits of Working Together
The kids will work together on a project to reach a common goal.
"There is no screen in team. Television, computer, and telephone screens weren't missed as the kids put their heads together to plan, strategize and accomplish their goals."
Month 10: Equipping Kids for Life's Little Errands
Even though they can't drive yet, they can come along to run errands and see that the toilet paper doesn't buy itself, the car doesn't fill itself with gas, and the shampoo doesn't automatically refill.
"Each time I do something they could do for themselves, I reinforce their sense that they are owed certain things. That "I deserve it" mentality irks me more that any other aspect of youth entitlement."
Month 11: It's About Others
This month Wyma challenges her kids to serve others, even in a small way, and to be obedient to act when they feel the nudge.
"If we're racing around and our calendars are full, it's hard to find the time to share God's love. It's hard to see opportunities to serve when we're blinded by our own needs."
Month 12: Minding Our Manners
Manners can include a lot of things...ladies first, look people in the eye, but Wyma said the main goal was for the kids to get outside themselves and consider others.
"Isn't that at the heart of all our entitlement issues? The obsession with being first in everything? Searching for significance through achievement and self-promotion, ending up ahead and on top?"
There you have it! I think it is worth reading and I really enjoyed all of the author's stories that went along with each month. It definitely wasn't easy and her kids did plenty of whining and complaining, as mine would, but I think this topic of youth entitlement is important to consider as we raise up our little warriors. My kids already do chores but this way of looking at it makes those jobs more meaningful and also helps me see that there are many more things they are able to and should do for themselves. As a mom, I tend to get overwhelmed by all the things I should "do" so I hope this doesn't come across as a giant to-do list. That is why the author took an entire year and looked at it as equipping rather than just being a taskmaster. I hope this was helpful, I haven't done a book summary since I was in school (very rusty!) but felt the nudge since the topic struck a chord with me and other moms as well. Happy reading! Jaymi